Do you also love toasties and are you looking for delicious recipes to try something different? When thinking of a toastie, many people quickly think of a cheese toastie or a ham and cheese toastie. But did you know there are endless possibilities with a toastie? You can endlessly vary with the fillings, but you can also use all kinds of bread.
If you are looking for tips to make the best toastie and need tasty toastie ideas, you are in the right place. Discover my favorite toastie recipes and enjoy a delicious lunch or a tasty toastie at another time.
How to make the best toasties
How do you make a toastie? You can make a delicious toastie in various ways. You can use a pan to fry the toastie or prepare it in the oven. However, toastie makers are the most popular. My personal preference is a contact grill, because you can make all kinds of toasties in it.
Making a toastie in a toastie maker
In toastie makers with special toastie plates, such as this sandwich maker, not every type of bread fits. This can be tricky with certain toastie recipes, for example, for pita toasties or toasties made from Turkish bread in this article. But if you mainly make toasties from slices of bread, then such a toastie maker is also a great option.
Making a toastie in a contact grill
I personally like to use a contact grill because you can vary with different types of bread for your toastie. The shape of the bread doesn’t matter here, unlike with a toastie maker.
I also find it very convenient if the plates of a contact grill can be removed, as they are easier to clean. This is possible with this toastie maker. With this last one, you can also bake both toasties and waffles, and you can grill other things with it because the baking plates are removable.
Delicious toastie variations? 5x great toastie ideas
Toasties are especially popular as a lunch dish, but actually, you can eat them anytime. Enjoy a toastie, for example, as a (Sunday) breakfast or make a quick toastie for dinner when you have little time. But what can you put on a toastie? Here are 5 delicious toastie variations for you.

Toastie variation 1: Turkish bread toastie with white cheese, za’atar, and tahini dip
For this toastie, you can both cut a large Turkish bread (for example, baked according to this Turkish bread recipe) into pieces or use small Turkish rolls about 15 centimeters in diameter. Cut the bread in half and crumble about 75 grams of white cheese over it. Sprinkle this with ½ teaspoon of za’atar, cover with the other half of the bread, and bake in a toastie maker.
For the dip, mix 100 grams of tahini (sesame paste) with 1 teaspoon of ground cumin and 2 teaspoons of lemon juice in a large bowl with a whisk. This becomes a thick mixture. Thin this by pouring cold water in while whisking until the dip has the consistency of yogurt. Season the sauce with salt and pepper if desired and serve it with this warm Turkish bread toastie.

Toastie variation 2: mozzarella-pesto toastie
Super simple but always delicious: a mozzarella-pesto toastie. Use thick slices of white bread and spread both slices on one side with pesto (for example, homemade with this pesto recipe). Slice a ball of mozzarella, let it drain on kitchen paper, and top the bread with it. Season with some freshly ground black pepper and sprinkle some toasted pine nuts on top.
Cover with the other slice of bread (with the pesto side facing inwards) and bake your toastie in a toastie maker until the cheese is melted and the bread is golden brown. Drizzle the toastie with some balsamic cream before serving.

Toastie variation 3: toastie with cheddar and cured bacon on sourdough bread
This toastie variation is a great alternative to the classic ham and cheese toastie. Cut thick slices of white sourdough bread. The slightly tangy taste of the bread goes very well with the rich flavor of the cured bacon and cheddar. Cut 2-3 slices of cured bacon into thin strips per toastie and mix them with 50-60 grams of grated cheddar cheese. Spread this mixture between two slices of sourdough bread and bake in a toastie maker. Warm some apple syrup in a pan and serve it as a dip with the toastie.

Toastie variation 4: pulled chicken toastie
This toastie is ideal if you want to use a leftover pulled chicken or you can use this pulled chicken recipe to make a new batch. Cut thick slices of sturdy (multigrain) bread and top them with the pulled chicken. Sprinkle some grated young cheese on top, cover with another slice of bread, and bake in a toastie maker. Serve the pulled chicken toastie with barbecue sauce as a dip.

Toastie variation 5: pita toastie with halloumi, mozzarella and rose harissa
You can use store-bought pitas for this recipe, but even better is to bake them yourself according to this pita recipe. It’s also the perfect way to use up leftover pitas (possibly from the freezer). Cut a pita open and spread 2-3 teaspoons of rose harissa on one side. Top this with equal parts coarsely grated halloumi and torn mozzarella. The mozzarella melts beautifully, while the halloumi retains a bit more structure. This gives the best combination of creamy and chewy. Place the other side of the pita on top and bake in a toastie maker. Serve the pita toastie with pomegranate molasses as a dip. You can find both rose harissa and pomegranate molasses in the Middle Eastern section of the supermarket.
Photos: Erik Spronk
Delen met vrienden:
- Click to print (Opens in new window) Print
- Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
- Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
- Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
- Click to share on Telegram (Opens in new window) Telegram
- Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp
- Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
Gerelateerd
U kunt niet meer reageren.
Reacties op oudere recepten sluiten automatisch na 180 dagen om de kwaliteit van discussies te waarborgen.