- Regular feeding:</
Baking with sourdough isn’t always straightforward. There are various problems you might encounter with your sourdough starter, a pure sourdough bread or a hybrid bread. In this article, I discuss the most common problems.
I received a lot of help from Chris regarding sourdough issues and questions. He works daily with various types of sourdough and knows the problems you can encounter when baking sourdough bread. Our goal was to address the most common issues as thoroughly as possible, not only identifying the causes but also providing solutions. This ensures it will be truly useful for home bakers.
Good to note that different factors can lead to the same problem. It is often a matter of testing and finding the best solution for your specific situation. Every bread, every sourdough starter, and every recipe is unique. You might need to experiment with the mentioned solutions and adjust them to work optimally for your situation.
Are you mainly looking for general bread baking tips? Then check out my articles on baking your own bread and shaping dough.

The common sourdough questions and problems I discuss in this article:
- My sourdough starter is not becoming active.
- There is a layer of water on my sourdough starter.
- What is hooch?
- There is mould on my sourdough.
- My sourdough starter is less active than usual.
- My sourdough starter smells like acetone.
- My sourdough starter collapses after feeding.
- I forgot to feed my sourdough starter.
- The sourdough dough is not rising.
- How do I get large holes in my sourdough bread?
- My sourdough bread is very dense and heavy.
- My sourdough bread is very flat and not nicely rounded.
- My sourdough bread is very sour.
- How do I maintain my sourdough starter when I go on holiday?
My sourdough starter is not becoming active
‘Why is my sourdough starter not becoming active’ is a frequently asked question. There can be various reasons why a sourdough starter is not becoming active. These are the most common causes and solutions:
- Young starter: If you have just started with your sourdough starter, it can take a few days before you see clear signs of activity. During the first few days, other bacteria may be dominant before the beneficial wild yeasts and bacteria take over. My main tip is to be patient. Keep feeding your starter daily and look for signs of activity like bubbles and an increase in volume.
- Temperature: Sourdough microbes are sensitive to temperature. If it is too cold, they can become inactive, while extreme heat can kill them. Keep your starter in a place with a stable temperature between 20-25°C (68-77°F). If your house is very cold, consider finding a warm spot, such as near an oven or in a special fermentation proofing box.
- Quality of flour: The quality and type of flour you use are important. Some types of flour contain more nutrients and natural yeasts than others. Use high-quality, unbleached, and preferably organic flour. If it does not work with regular flour, try whole wheat or rye flour, as these often contain more microbes.
- Hygiene: While you want wild yeasts and bacteria to get into your starter, you do not want harmful bacteria or moulds to have a chance. Ensure that all equipment (jar, spoon, bowl) is clean when handling the starter.
- Feeding frequency: Regularly feeding your starter is essential to keep the microbes active and healthy. Feed your starter daily at least in the beginning, or even twice a day if your home is very warm.
If you still do not see any activity after addressing all these factors, consider starting over and pay special attention to the quality of your ingredients and the ambient temperature.
There is a layer of water on my sourdough starter
If there is a layer of water on your sourdough, it can have several causes. A layer of water on your sourdough starter may have different causes and thus different solutions. Some potential causes and solutions:
- Insufficient mixing: It may be that the ingredients in your sourdough are not well mixed, causing water to accumulate at the top. Make sure to stir the starter thoroughly at each feeding so that all ingredients are well combined and the moisture is evenly distributed.
- Environmental factors: The ambient temperature and humidity can affect the condition of your sourdough. In very humid conditions, more water can form on the sourdough. Try storing the sourdough in a slightly warmer and well-ventilated place to reduce excess moisture. This is especially applicable if you store the sourdough at room temperature; in the fridge, this is less the case.
- Over fermentation: If your sourdough has risen too long before you feed it again, more water can form on the sourdough. Make sure to feed the sourdough regularly and monitor the fermentation process to prevent it from going too far.
- Overfeeding: Overfeeding your sourdough can result in excess moisture accumulating at the top. Try adjusting the ratios when feeding your sourdough. Reduce the amount of water or increase the amount of flour to thicken the consistency.
Here are some general solutions for excess water on your sourdough:
- You can carefully scoop off the excess water with a spoon or dab it off with a clean cloth. Make sure to keep a part of the healthy sourdough and not throw away too much.
- If the problem of excess water occurs repeatedly and your sourdough does not seem to improve, it may be useful to refresh your sourdough completely. Start with a new starter by taking a small part of the old starter and mixing it with fresh flour and water. By starting the process again, you may create a healthier and more balanced sourdough.
- Note: every sourdough is different, and small changes in consistency are quite normal. As long as there are no signs of mould, such as a strong rotten smell or unusual discoloration, the chances are good that your sourdough is still healthy, even with a layer of water on it.
What is hooch?
Does your sourdough have a brown or gray layer on top? This is hooch. ‘Hooch’ is a term used to describe the liquid that sometimes develops on top of sourdough when it has not been fed for a while. This liquid is a byproduct of the fermentation of the sourdough and can vary in color from transparent to darker gray, brown, or even black, depending on the type of flour you use and how long it has been since the last feeding.
Hooch is an alcoholic liquid. If there is a layer on your sourdough, it usually means that the yeasts and bacteria in your sourdough need more food. Although it is not harmful or dangerous, it can affect the taste of your sourdough if the hooch is not removed or the sourdough is not stirred.
Stirring the sourdough
If you see a small amount of hooch on your sourdough, you can simply stir it before feeding the sourdough starter. If there is a lot of hooch, it is better to pour it off first before feeding the sourdough. If you notice a strong, unpleasant odor or if the hooch has a very dark color, your sourdough may have been without food for too long, and you should consider starting a new sourdough.
In general, hooch is a sign that you need to feed your sourdough more often, especially if you store it outside the fridge. Daily feeding can help to prevent hooch formation in sourdough stored outside the fridge. If you store your sourdough in the fridge, you should feed it about once a week.

There is mould on my sourdough
Is there mould on your sourdough? Then it is important to take action. A sourdough with mould is not safe to use. These are the steps you can take:
- Remove the mould layer: Use a clean spoon or spatula to carefully remove the mouldy parts of the sourdough. Make sure to do this without mixing the mould with the rest of the sourdough.
- Check the sourdough thoroughly: Carefully inspect the sourdough and check for other signs of mould growth, such as discolorations (green, blue, gray, or even black spots or stripes), unusual textures like white or colored fuzz, or unpleasant smells like a musty or spoiled odor. If you smell something strong and unusual, it may indicate mould growth. If the mould has spread deeply into the sourdough, it may be necessary to discard the entire starter and start over.
- Make a new sourdough: If you need to discard the sourdough due to mould growth, make a new starter. Read here how to make a sourdough starter. Use clean materials and ensure you use the correct ratios of flour and water. Keep a close eye on the new sourdough for any signs of mould or other problems.
- Don’t forget: Mould growth on your sourdough is not normal and it is not safe to use for baking. If you see mould on your sourdough starter or have doubts, it is wise to discard the mould. Sometimes this will also mean that you need to make a new starter. Safety always comes first, so be alert to signs of mould and work cleanly and precisely to keep the quality of your sourdough starter good.
- Prevent recurrence: To prevent mould growth in the sourdough, there are several measures you can take. Always use clean materials when working with the sourdough. Keep the sourdough covered with a minimally breathable material to prevent unwanted microorganisms from entering. Store the sourdough at 4-6°C (39-43°F), in a fridge with a stable temperature.
My sourdough starter is less active than usual
If your sourdough starter suddenly seems less active, there can be various causes. Here are some possible reasons and solutions:
- Temperature: The activity of a sourdough starter can significantly vary with different (ambient) temperatures. Cold temperatures can slow down activity, while warmer temperatures can accelerate activity. Check if there have been recent temperature fluctuations in your house. Try to maintain a consistent temperature where you feed and store the starter.
- Feeding frequency: If you do not feed the sourdough starter often enough, the yeasts and bacteria can become starved, resulting in reduced activity. Feed your starter regularly, especially if it is kept at room temperature.
- Flour type: The quality and type of flour you use can influence activity. Some types of flour contain more nutrients and enzymes beneficial for the microorganisms in your starter.
- Contamination: Other microbes can compete with the yeasts and bacteria in your starter, reducing activity. Ensure good hygiene when feeding your starter. Use clean jars and utensils, and wash your hands well beforehand.
- Age of the starter: Older starters that have been used for months or even years can sometimes go through periods of reduced activity. In that case, you might consider refreshing part of your starter by starting a new starter and combining it with the old one.
It is important to be patient with your sourdough starter. Even if it seems less active, a consistent feeding regime and attention to the above factors can help restore its activity.
My sourdough starter smells like acetone
If your starter smells like acetone, it can indicate a disturbance in the balance of microorganisms in the starter. An acetone-like smell can occur when certain bacteria are too prevalent or when the starter becomes unbalanced. This can happen due to factors like temperature fluctuations, irregular feeding schedules, or insufficient aeration.
Here are a few possible solutions for a starter that smells like acetone:
- Regular feeding:</
Delen met vrienden:
- Click to print (Opens in new window) Print
- Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
- Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
- Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
- Click to share on Telegram (Opens in new window) Telegram
- Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp
- Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
Gerelateerd
Beste,
Hoeveel desemstarter gebruik ik voor een brood van ongeveer 1kg.
Hoeveelheid starter op hoeveelheid bloem ?
Bij voorbaat dank.
Grutjes Nadine.
U kunt niet meer reageren.
Reacties op oudere recepten sluiten automatisch na 180 dagen om de kwaliteit van discussies te waarborgen.